Elf Beheading?

[Jason]

No: HPFGUIDX 102347

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Lady Macbeth" 
<ladymacbeth at l...> wrote:
> Tiggersong wrote:
> Sure, it's taking a life.  But wouldn't it also be a kindness?  
Kreacher's
> *not* happy at all.  Wouldn't it be kinder to him to ... put him 
out of his
> misery?
> 
> Lady Macbeth wrote:
> Personally, I agree with you.  However, there are many who would 
not, and I
> am certain that Jo is one of them.  In writing OotP, she made a 
very vivid
> point about what Harry and Co. thought of the elf heads on the 
wall.  That
> suggests that it's also how she (as the writer) feels.  Yes, it 
WOULD be the
> humane thing for him.  > 
SNIP


> -Lady Macbeth





Add me to the list that would have Kreachers head as a door stop for 
the kitchen door and a nice big tea tray mounted to his neck and 
shoulders to form a nice table for a corner of the drawing room. :-)

I'd also have Winky carted off to St Mungo's pet ward for some long 
term care. (Apologies to Neville)

My verdict on Kreacher only comes after he betrayed the order. 
Before then I'd have done my best to make friends with him.


Jason