CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 20, Hagrid's Tale

[huntergreen_3]

No: HPFGUIDX 102451

Petra:
> [5] Has a question arisen from this chapter
> for you? Pose it
please! :)

Jen: >>Yes. Why, JKR Why?!? I can't read OOTP without skipping over
this chapter. I guess the giants are supposed to be another example
of an oppressd group, but that's covered by the House Elves,
Werewolfs, Goblins, Centaurs, etc. I just can't see the point.<<

HunterGreen:
Neither can I. This may be horrible to say, but considering the 
personalities/tendencies of the giants, I can see why they were 
oppressed in the first place. They hardly seem more than violent 
creatures. The House Elves, Werewolves and Goblins I can get 
concerned about. I also find myself skimming over that chapter (but 
I'm not a big Hagrid fan either), but I sense that we haven't heard 
the end of the giants (or at least the end of Grawp).