Elf Beheading

tyler maroney tmar78 at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 22 17:06:27 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 102454

Alina:
I don't think Sirius could've set Kreacher free even
before he offered 12 Grimmauld Place to the Order for
Headquarters, because then Kreacher would've been able
to tell the Malfoys that Sirius is in London and 
living int he old house and they'd find ways to use
this information against him, they could've gotten him
thrown back in Azkaban.

Tyler replies:
Not necessarily.  The Malfoys knew that Sirius was in
London for most of OotP,  and nothing came of it.  And
I'm sure they were able to deduce where he must be
hiding out.  As long as the Secret Keeper didn't
reveal the location of #12,  Sirius was perfectly
safe.

Now,  one could argue that while the Malfoys could not
enter #12,  they'd still know where it is.  I've been
giving this one some thought and I've come up w/ a
theory.  Its a little out there,  admittedly,  so bear
w/ me.  What if #12 had been moved from its original
location?  I mean,  would the Blacks (muggle-haters to
the extreme) live in a muggle neighborhood?  I'm
thinking maybe the house was originally in the middle
of nowhere and DD used a portkey-type spell to move it
to London so they'd have quicker access to the MoM. 
Is that possible?  I know,  I'm probably wrong on this
one; its just a thought.



=====
Some see the glass as half-empty,  some see the glass as half-full.  I see the glass as too big.   ~  George Carlin


		
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Read only the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard.
http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail 




More information about the HPforGrownups archive