SS/PS comments (BEWARE RON=DD POST)

casmir2012 casmir2012 at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 22 15:59:05 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 102459

I have heard some excellent "clues" that seemingly support the 
theory of Ron (or one of the twins even) being Dumbledore...but one 
thing stops me from believing it myself.  The fact that Dumbledore 
had his own childhood (remember that the OWL tester remembered when 
Dumbldore took his tests...did things she'd never seen before).  
Dumbledore has his own family (that have been only mentioned, true, 
but Dumbledore never lies...according to JKR.)

Also, it would be a very weak plot line, indeed, if Dumbledore was 
Ron or a Twin and with all that foreknowledge was still unable to 
prevent Voldemort from taking power.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive