Trelawney, true Seer

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 102502

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "evita2fr" <Snarryfan at a...> 
wrote:
> Personally I think that she's a real Seer, but she transform all 
she 
> see to be like her Gran or Aunt, I don't remember.
> 
> She thinks that if she saw a rainbow, everyone would think that 
she's 
> not up to it so she changes it for something horrible. But what she 
> see is true. It's her interpretation who's problematic.
> 
> Neville's cup and the Grim was already discussed, but I add that.
> 
> In POA, she said that she saw that the exam will be about the 
crystal 
> Ball. Hermione said next "what a surprise, it's her who make the 
> exams, she didn't see anything".
> 
> It seemed true, and we forgot it.
> 
> But...about what was the Divination OWLs ? :D
> 
> Crystal Ball!
> 
> Christelle


oh, I like that. So, you are saying that Trelawney could have made 
more true predictions  than two if only she interpreted them 
correctly?


What do you mean by the way by "problematic interpretation"? That she 
sees one thng but tells to other people that she saw something 
totally different or that she just gives different meaning to her 
true vision?

Now my head starts spinning, but I still like it. :o)

Is she granddaughter or Great granddaughter of Cassandra? She must 
have inherited some gift at least. 


Alla