Pensieve Again

rzl46 rzl46 at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 23 23:27:26 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 102629

Please forgive me for not giving a post reference.  Just got back 
from a day at the hospital.  Anyway, I was really enjoying all the 
posts about the nature of the Pensieve--about whether it recorded 
things as they actually were, or if they are colored by the person 
who originally owned the thoughts or memories.  A question occurred 
to me that could really shed some light on how we understand the 
Pensieve to operate.  I'll pose it to you all.  If Harry were to 
recored his memory of the Thestral lesson in OOP in the Pensieve, and 
Hermione and Ron were to view it from that source, would they be able 
to see the Thestrals or not?

My vote is yes.  Curious what the rest of you all think.

MaggieB--who is really hoping to get some interesting responses to 
chew on.  





More information about the HPforGrownups archive