Droobles Best Blowing Gum
theultimatesen
senderellabrat at aol.com
Thu Jun 24 19:04:22 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 102730
Hettiebe:
> I can't help feeling that Neville's sole talent, herbology, is
going
> to come in here somewhere. It's obviously being kept up in the
story
> for some reason. So it might be a clue or anagram of a plant or
> process of which we know nothing as yet.
Me:
Reading this really sparked something in my mind. Bear with me guys.
I really feel like I had a burst of genius. What if it has nothing to
do with an anagram? (I'm not sure how long Alice has been giving
Neville the wrappers. We really don't have proof of that as far as I
can remember NOR do we know how often they go to visit his parents..
so with that aside & out of the equation,let me lay this out). I'm
sure when Neville & Gran go to visit they talk to his parents about
Neville's school and how much he likes/is good at Herbology right?
I'm sure they just don't stand there silently looking at them. Gums
have a lot of PLANT BASED ingredients. What if Alice is giving him
the wrappers because a particular plant (possibly a plant based
ingredient in Droobles) is what they need to snap out of their
current state. It could also tie in with (I don't have my book on me
right now) the fact Neville thought he did ok on his Potions OWLs. If
he can get through an OWL level exam without Snape hovering over him
making him incredibly nervous, he may be pretty good at Potions which
would tie in beautifully with his Herbology knack. Maybe we're
clutching desperately to anagrams which is what JKR wants us to do as
to throw us off the scent. **Seeking cover for the cannon firing
squad** =o)
Sen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive