CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 20, Hagrid's Tale

[huntergreen_3]

No: HPFGUIDX 102797

Geo wrote:
>>The current faction of the giants are more
into killing and maiming. He could just simply portkey them into a
spot to create chaos and havoc and force the MoM into diverting
resources to controlling the giants and obliviating people who've
seen them. <<

HunterGreen:
Then why is he bothering to set up relations with them at all? I 
agree that if you portkeyed a bunch of giants into the middle of 
Diagon Alley it wouldn't end well, but it seems like that'd work 
better if the giants had no prior knowledge that this was going to 
happen (if he tricked them into a portkey), because they'd be 
confused and confusion would lead to anger. Then again, this seems 
like too broad a plan for Voldemort, all evidence points at him doing 
things in a quiet, sinister way. (which brings me back to wondering 
why he cares about the giants in the first place...seems like the 
goblins would be a better place to concentrate).