Pensieve = Security Camera? / the prank
mnaper2001
mnaperrone at aol.com
Fri Jun 25 18:27:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 102827
> > Alice:
> > But this would mean that having a Pensieve would be like having
360
> > vision and senses all the time - albeit only in retrospect.
> > Wouldn't people USE that a lot more? Just one idea: the examiner
could
> > look into his Pensieve after the exam and check whether anybody
had
> > been cheating, talking etc.
Valky:
> This is a boon for the argument that the pensieve is not objective.
>
> Truly if it were so would the Wizard World use it for these things.
>
Ally:
But whose to say everyone has a pensieve? Only DD appears to have
one. Just like not everyone has a time turner or a Marauder's Map or
an invisibility cloak.
The fact that DD said its useful to gain perspective on an event and
the fact that it showed things Snape apparently wasn't consciously
aware of when they were happening (eg the Marauders conversation
about werewolves) makes me think it takes all of the conscious and
subconscious aspects of the memory and puts them all on display for
you.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive