Dudley, the prophecy

[halli]

No: HPFGUIDX 102862

Phil:
> Dudley is considerably older than Harry: he's mobile at the 
> very least.
<snip PS quotes>
> I read this as indicating that Dudley is at least crawling and 
> maybe a toddler.
> 
> On the other hand he cannot be that much older than Harry since 
> they are both transferring from primary to secondary school at 
> the same time, so he must be within the same year group.
 
Gina:
> Phil, I did not mean to imply the same year. Dudley probably 
> is older than Harry, but did the prophecy specify a YEAR of birth? 
> I thought it only said the end of July and Dudley's birthday is 
> obviously the end of July b/c Harry's is a very few days later.


halli:
       Hey, I would like to point out that Dudley is probably only 
one or two months older than Harry, because supposing Harry is a 
year old, Dudley and Harry would be mobile at that time so 
yeah...also, Dudley's birthday is...like one of you said, I'm not sure 
who...before school ends, presumably May, June or July.