Why didn't Sirius contact anyone?

meriaugust meriaugust at yahoo.com
Sat Jun 26 03:09:48 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 102875

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Inge" <Elvishooked at h...> 
wrote:
> In PoA we are told that Sirius is captured and sent directly to 
> Azkaban, without a trial. Yet it seems that Sirius had over 12 
hours 
> from he left Godrics Hollow, untill he is captured. Why on earth 
> didn't he contact anyone. Maybe noone knew that he and Pettigrew 
> swopped the secretkeeping, but it seems (in PoA) that Lupin would 
> have believed him if he had told, and Dumbledore as well. How come 
he 
> didn't get in touch with the Order at that time? That would have 
> helped him catch pettigrew, and he would have Dumbledores support. 
> This would also most certainly have prevented him from going to 
> Azkaban. Yet dispite his many options, he chose to chase him on 
his 
> own...? 

Meri: Well, and I am a Sirius defender saying this, old Snuffles 
isn't known for rational behavior in difficult situations. Sirius, 
realizing there must be a traitor somewhere in the Maurauder's 
midst, had just come upon the dead bodies of his best friend/brother 
and his wife and was told that he couldn't have custody of Harry, 
his last link to them. Rational thought is not an option here. Nor 
it seems is contacting DD. Even Hagrid, who was trusted with 
carrying Harry, didn't see the man til twenty four hours later. 

all if this caused me to rethink the way things happened in 
> Godrics Hollow. Lupin stubbeles over the fact the harry hear both 
> Lily and certainly James voice when is in contact with the 
demntors. 
> Could there be some details about the death of Lily and James that 
we 
> haven't been told yet, and is that why Sirius doesn't contact 
anyone?

Meri: Well, I would say that we do not know even close to the whole 
story of that fateful Halloween night. Though I am sure that Lily 
and James are both legitimately dead. 

> Lene, who firmly believes that a cup of cocoa can solve anything...

Meri 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive