Mind Healer (was Re: Some questions/comments about OOTP (LONG))

[evita2fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 102902

 
> Alla:
> 
> 
> 
> No, I am not expecting Dumbledore to sent Mind Healer from St. 
Mungo 
> to Privet Drive :), although it would have been nice, but if he 
cared 
> about Harry as much as he claimed could he I don't know at least 
ask 
> Molly to come over and talk to Harry.
> 
> Unhealed trauma of Cedric's death alone would have been enough to 
> send a child over the edge and Harry saw so much more pain.



It what I found frightning, Alla. I don't think that the 'Mind 
Healer' exist in the WW.

The best example we know is Harry, because we see his life.

Cho is still upset with Cedric's death 6 months after. Looks like her 
only help was her friends and maybe her parents.

Ginny just was abduct in a Chamber with a monster of 1000 years-old 
and so and the cure is a cup of chocolat, and...nothing.

Hagrid spent many *months* in Azkaban, and...nothing.

I hesitate to say the next example. I'm a Snape fan and I like Harry 
and wanted to shout when I saw that they sent him in Privet Drive 
after they saw that it wasn't a good idea. If they let him alone 
again...

I'll say it. In the Shack, Harry said that Snape looked crazy and 
that he never saw him like that. I think that it's true, Snape was 
crazy. It's like when someone was shot and refuse to see a psy. The 
next time that they hear a bang (car or firecracker), they're scared 
to death and/or begin to aim with the gun they just bought.
I don't know the good term, when someone relive a horrible memory 
with the good stimuli.
And Lupin+Black+Shack+James'Memory(Harry) is enough to sent Snape in 
the Prank time.

All that to say, I won't be surprised (horrified, yes but not 
surprised) if we learn that after the Prank, the aftermath was "it 
was only a joke, you're not hurt so it was not grave, take a lemon 
drop and go back to bed. And never talk about this, no harm done 
after all!".

So, a student face a werewolf and...nothing.

Hermione (and 4 other persons) was a statue for many months and 
again, nothing.

Two 11-years-old (Draco and Harry) saw a strange thing drinking the 
blood of a unicorn.

The two first tasks in the Triwizard tournament, ect...

It could be a demonstration of the spirit of the WW, where what's 
dangerous and inadmissible for us is OK for them, but if the Wizards 
should learn something from the Muggle, it would be the heal of the 
mind.

Maybe the only help that the Longbottom received was only spells and 
potions, and they never tried something else.


Christelle.