Conspiracies Unlimited (was Re: Neville and the Prophecy)

Jen Reese stevejjen at earthlink.net
Mon Jun 28 13:22:09 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 103077

Kneasy:
> All in all, I have my doubts as to the likelihood of the Veela 
chorus
> being the Third Imperio! - assuming that there was one. 
> If someone  ttwisted my arm, I'd plump for Godric's Hollow; but
> who placed it? The 'good' side, as an extra measure of protection
> against the influence of Voldy? Or the 'baddies' - to make him more
> susceptible?

Jen: An Imperio on baby Harry that he never remembered or mentioned, 
then suddenly recalls at the graveyard? I guess I'm not much of a 
conspriracy theorist in training--that's just too way out there for 
my tastes.

Besides, in the graveyard when Voldemort Imperio'd Harry, Harry 
recalls the 'feeling' for the third time in his life, not the actual 
curse. Since the feeling of the Imperio and the Veelas is a similar 
sensation, I'm putting my money on that. 

And any Imperio at Godric's Hollow would wear off long before Harry 
ever meets LV, unless Dumbledore trained Petunia in the fine art of 
the Unforgiveables. Hey, maybe that's why Harry was such a compliant 
kid ;).







More information about the HPforGrownups archive