FAQs: Lily died before James?

colfubster at optonline.net colfubster at optonline.net
Mon Jun 28 20:04:44 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 103184

Gorda:
>JKR updated the FAQ section of her official site and this was one of 
>the updates:
>
>"At the end of 'Goblet of Fire', in which order should Harry's 
>parents have come out of the
>wand?
>
>James first, then Lily." <snip>
>
>So, Lily was killed  before James? James was NOT at GH, as we have 
>been speculating for a while? What to make of this??!!!


I saw this. My guess is that V did not kill James at the door. He 
only stunned him. V then went straight to kill Harry, but had to kill 
Lily to get her out of his way. James is still alive when the house 
blows up because of the failed AK. V is vapor, so Peter (who followed 
V to GH) take V's wand and kills James because James knows Peter 
betrayed them.

This proves that V really was only shooting for Harry.

colfubster





More information about the HPforGrownups archive