Death to James in Two Variations

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 103269

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Steve" <asian_lovr2 at y...> 
wrote:
> Well, as difficult and confusing as it is, and as much as I don't 
want
> to believe it, it seems that I have become the advocate for James
> being killed after Lily.
> 
> Among a million other questions, we must now ask how and when DID
> James die?
> 
Hi Steve,
You are not alone. I am pretty darn sure that this is the real 
story. My GOF has Lily coming out first, but I DON'T CARE Jo says 
it's t'other way round so I am gonna pencil it in myself!

Your Theories are good BBoy but i came upon one just now while I was 
mulling over the contents of todays posts and JKRs new FAQ answers 
in my mind and Voila! I have a thought that answers the questions.

LV is telling the truth in PS 'the man with two faces' and JKR is 
making no mistake because.....

Voldie killed someone before Godrics Hollow. Someone who looked like 
James someone he truly believed to be James. But it wasn't James. It 
was a decoy James as once seen the Remus/James switching spell 
theory that nobody actually knows is dead because a DE has now 
replaced the missing person and is operating in secret.That would 
leave a someone now alive who isn't who they appear to be.

.............oh no i just thought up another..................

or nobody ever found James body and the body at Godrics Hollow was 
every bit James except for what was hidden behind the closed eyelids.
This ones been said before though.

Valky