[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape like teacher

[Ashley]

No: HPFGUIDX 103271


Alla:


Sorry, not IMO. McGonagall is strict with everybody. Snape is 
arbitrarily unfair. (really don't want to get into my "he is not only 
unfair, but abusive" mood right now) 

Even if you disagree that he is abusive, I really don't see how 
anybody can question Snape's unfairness.

Even though the end of OoP hints that Snape and McGonagall have 
friendly relationship, in my mind Snape has a veeeeeeery long way to 
go before he becomes as good a teacher as Minerva is. :o)


If he is 'abusive' then there could only be one reason why he is like that. His love life is an ultimate failure, because if you don't have someone to love you or someone to love at all...then you feel like you should take it out on everyone else.

I agree to a point that he is unfair to his students, but maybe there is a deep reason for it. Some of the stupidest people (or clumsiest) come out to be great people if they have the right guidance. Usually those people have been treated like a baby all their life, and perhaps Snape is giving them a push to be an individual.

SweetOnGoo *holds breath and waits for someone to yell at her thoughts*


		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Address AutoComplete - You start. We finish.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]