Lily died before James? - No Room for Error.

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 103300

SSSusan:
>>> This isn't a challenge to your budding theory or anything, but 
one question I have is this:  Is it possible that Voldy killed Lily, 
then went & killed James, and then finally cast the spell which 
scarred Harry & vaporized himself--just as we've all thought, only 
with the parents getting coffed in reverse order than we'd thought--
and it's just that Priori Incantatum was HALTED before we could see 
what that spell "looked like"??
Or is my logic faulty here?<<<


Kneasy: 
> Erm, I don't think that's  possible.
> Unless my logic is faulty (getting old, getting old) the spell  
> that appears directly after Bertha should be the final one he cast 
> at GH, the one that rebounded. Unless of course, someone else used 
> his wand, which would be a bit of a swizz IMO. For  the sequence  
> to end before we get to that spell would require Voldy to be 
> destroyed before tackling Lily and James. Or it wasn't the rebound 
> from Harry that nailed him, but another spell entirely.
> Or have I misunderstood your point?
> 

SSSusan again:
No, darn it, you've not misunderstood--MY logic is indeed faulty.  (I 
shouldn't even TRY when it comes to these things!) You're quite 
right.  Whatever vaporized Voldy would've come BETWEEN the two Potter 
parents & Frank Bryce in PI. 

Though, now, apparently JKR's corrected her website again, Kneasy, 
saying LILY came first.  Phooey.  Does that mean the evil chuckling 
will end?

Siriusly Snapey Susan