FAQs: Lily died before James?

[Brenda M.]

No: HPFGUIDX 103333

> Cindy jenkins wrote: 
> Note to all!
> 
> I posted this earlier, but I guess it didn't go through.  The web 
page says "LILY first, then James".  (Emphasis mine.)  The original 
poster simply misquoted it, I think.  Please, go see for yourself! <<

Bren now:

But it doesn't make sense. The rest of reply stays the same as 
though her original message was meant to say "James first, then 
Lily". If Lily was indeed supposed to come out first, then there is 
no need to talk about how her US editor was wrong, no? The rest of 
post just doesn't make sense with "Lily first, then James" beginning.

Or what about "That's how it appears in my original manuscript" 
statement? Her original edition has James first coming out then 
Lily, I have the British-Canadian version which is supposed to 
remain unchanged, I think.

I think "Lily first then James" is a hoax or some hacking. She 
should have changed the whole post if she meant it.

Isn't it more logical that she put this under her "Rumour" section 
notifying the change rather than just simply switching the names 
without any sign?

Bren, thoroughly confused