Voldy!James? (Re: Lily died before James? - No Room for Error.)

[Brenda M.]

No: HPFGUIDX 103345

>>> Kneasy wrote:
> There's been much discussion going back to I don't know when over 
> the order of the re-appearances from Voldy's wand. One frequently
> asked question that has never been satisfactorily answered is:
> "Where's the spell that destroyed Voldemort?"
> Now it is confirmed that James was the last to be killed and there 
is
> still no obvious answer to that question. Unless of course.....
> 
> Do you see where I'm going?
> 
> If James died last and that was also the spell that rebounded onto 
the
> caster to form Vapour!Mort from a Voldy who strangely didn't seem 
to
> leave a body behind (implied by Sirius) then Occams Razor leads 
one to
> the conclusion that Voldy!James is a definite possibility. 
> Possession, perhaps?
> 
> I've often idly wondered why Voldy's name doesn't crop up 
> whenever Harry  has his moments of memory recall - it's "He's
> coming!" Lupin seems surprised when Harry says he hears James's
> voice calling out the warning. Well, he would, wouldn't he, if he
> knows something different. 
> 
> Others may argue that the 'Third Party' used Voldy's wand to kill 
James,
> but then there's still that missing spell, the one that formed 
Vapour!Mort.
> Where is it? Something that traumatic should  be capable of recall.
> Why would somebody else use Voldy's wand anyway? Don't they have
> one of their own? I  can only recall one character that doesn't 
have a 
> properly functional wand - surely not, no - Hagrid? No, no. <<<


Bren now:

First *bow* to the greatest Conspiracy Theorist I've ever... "read".

But I'm afraid you have lost me. What exactly do you mean by "Voldy!
James"? Did you mean "Vapor!James"? My head is Siriusly hurting with 
all the "James first then Lily" and then "Lily first then James" and 
THEN the new title, etc etc.

Summon De-Confusion Squad, please!!

Bren