Moving to Sirius? (was: Lily died before James? - No Room for Error)

[Mandy]

No: HPFGUIDX 103391


> > Alla:
> > Ooo, the possibility to defend Sirius. :o) Bring it on.

> Bren now:
> Let me join you, Alla. It is downright preposterous and outrageous 
> that anyone will question Sirius' loyalty. You'd think the guy will 
> crack up after 12 years in Azkaban.
> Come on, Sirius is/was about the only real good thing Harry has/had 
> (other than Hermione and Ron). Leave him alone.



Mandy here:
I don't think anyone was or could questioning Sirius' loyalty. 

It more the fact that Siurus Black was an immature, petulant, 
selfish, arrogant, hypocritical, angry, sad and lonely boy who never 
really grew up that's often discussed by those of us who really don't 
like him.    

Of course, that is what makes Sirius such a fascinating character, 
along with Snape. It's their faults that make them so intriguing.  

Mandy, who though that seeing Gary Oldman play him on screen might 
have changed my mind but, fortunately, no.