HBP MUST have appeared in COS

[karenlyall666]

No: HPFGUIDX 103414

I'm having problems understanding why everyone seems to have decided 
that the 'Half Blood Prince' character must have appeared in Chamber 
of Secrets.

The title Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince could easily have 
worked for book 3 if Voldemort was the 'Prince' here's the important 
bit - referred to in THAT title.

None of the above negates the possibility of using the title in 
either book 3 or 6.  Just because JKR's titles have been very 
specific doesn't mean this is the only way to go.  They could just as 
easily (and specifically) called.

BK1 - HP and the Mysterious Package
BK2 - HP and the Heir of Slytherin
BK3 - HP and the Godfather
BK4 - HP and the Triwizard Tournament
BK5 - HP and the House of Black

Admittedly 'my' titles for book 3 & 5 are slightly weak, But Enid 
Blyton got away with murder with the titles for her Famous Five books.

Please tell me if I'm totally off my trolley due to new HP 
stimulation.  We want book 6, or at least an idea of when we're 
getting it...

karenlyall666