What shows up in Priori Incantatem? (Was Re: FAQs: Lily died before James?)

Phil Boswell phil_hp7 at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Jun 30 09:21:14 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 103596

"Debra" <hpsupergeek at y...> wrote:
[snip]
> And then there's that tried and 
> true question of why nothing came out of the wand that represented 
> the failed curse. And then, consequently, what *should* have come out 
> of the wand? Maybe an echo of the lightning bolt scar? 
> Some of these, probably the Cruciatus Curses, can be attributed to 
> the screams of pain the wand issued between some of the echoes. But 
> what happened to the others?

I believe that popular opinion is that the screams are indeed the
"Cruciatus" echoes.

I also think you have hit the nail on the head: what exactly would an
echo of an "Imperius" curse look like? Furthermore, what would the
echo of a failed "Avada Kedavra" look like? The ones which succeeded
produced echoes of the victims; there was no such victim of the failed
curse to show.

HTH HAND
-- 
Phil






More information about the HPforGrownups archive