Lupin and "Prince"

[rtb333]

No: HPFGUIDX 103611

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "carin_in_oh" <aldhelm at e...> 
wrote:
 Having read the last day's posts, I'm inclined to think GG is the 
HBP, not 
> Lupin, but that Lupin and his backstory will become central. Having 
GG be the HBP 
> would make all my worries about what "Prince" means disappear, and 
I'm thrilled to 
> think that the next book will have lots more on both GG and Lupi


Robert Now:

I have been following this thread to see if anyone comes to the same 
conclusions regarding the HBP.  I believe that the HBP is Godric 
Gryffindor.  Why?  It seems to me that since there was a huge dispute 
between SS and GG regarding admittence into Hogwarts, SS would bestow 
onto GG the title of the HBP.  This seems to me to be a logical 
solution.  With the information that we have from canon, it is 
difficult to rationalize another being the HBP.  

It would be nice to note all of the half bloods that we know about.  
(Don't forget Seamus)

Robert
"There is no good and evil.  There is only power and those too weak 
to seek it"-LV PS/SS