[HPforGrownups] Sloppy

[Kimberly]

No: HPFGUIDX 103635

 Confession.... right now Im VERY annoyed with J.K.
Am I the only one who spent hours yesterday reading loads of great 
posts concerning new theories on what happened at GH because of the 
information on J.K.'s website indicating that Lily actually died 
before James?

There were so many wonderful theories posted on here and people were 
going crazy on the new possibilities about the events that night.

Only to find out that it was sloppy work on J.K.'s side and she 
corrected (or re-corrected.... - or re-re-corrected) her own 
information - setting us all back with a feeling of ...... huh?

If she did it on purpose (confusing us by deliberately first saying 
James died first - then chaning it back to Lily died first - only to 
change it back again to James died first) - then it's not even funny 
anymore - and it's not fair!

Inge


*Kimberly's comment*
While I can identify with your frustration (I'm STILL not sure who died first, came out of the wind first, etc.), I can't say I'm annoyed with her.    I don't think she did it deliberately and with all of the facts she has to keep straight and details she tends to, I'm not surprised something like this happened.    She's human and doesn't have a pensieve to unload her thoughts into therefore, making a mistake is bound to happen.     Am I frustrated ?   Yes.    Do I want to know the truth ?  Yes.    But I'm going to wait until the dust settles and then check out the latest facts by JKR herself.    

Kimberly


 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]