HBP MUST have appeared in COS

[lavaluvn]

No: HPFGUIDX 103641


Cora <cburchak at t...> writes:
> This is why Voldemort settled on Harry rather than Neville as 
> the child of the prophecy. <snip> Voldemort identified with the 
> Half Blood as he himself is a Half Blood. Personally I think the
> HBP is Tom Riddle.

Neil <BrwNeil at a...> wrote:
> That would be rather a dirty trick on the part of Rowling.  I doubt 
> she would say that the HBP was neither Harry nor Voldemort and then
> make it Tom Riddle. After all Tom and Voldemort are the same person.
 

I tend to agree with you, I like other options better (Godric 
Griffindor, Hagrid, Lupin), but didn't Dobby differentiate between 
Voldemort and Tom Riddle in COS when trying to give Harry a 
clue?  "not...not He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, sir..."

The Other, Other Cheryl