Arthur is dead on JKR's page
kneazelkid
afleitas at bankrate.com
Wed Jun 30 16:54:32 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 103676
"kneazelkid" wrote:
Assuming that JKR's Web page is cannon (and I think it is), I
believe Arthur dies in the 6th book and that JKR has already written
his death. If you look under the information on the Weasley family
(under the tea cup) it says "Arthur Weasley WAS one of three
brothers" -- not "is," but "was." All othe characters on site are
referred to in the present tense (with the exception of those we
know are dead).
Now, of course, another explanation coudl be that one or more of
his brothers has died, but as we haven't been introduced to them,
they are not very likely to be killed in books 6 or 7 (although
anything is possible). If they died in the previous war, there
really is no reason for JKR not to give us this information,
as she does regarding Molly's realtives that were killed.
Anyone?
Antosha:
<snip>
Molly is referred to in the web site in the past tense: "Molly *was*
Molly Prewett." <snip> Besides, like others, I'm counting on Arthur
serving as Minister of Magic at least for a while...
Kneazelkid again:
But it says Molly "was" Prewett, because she WAS Prewett. She is no
longer a Prewett, so that example doesn't stand up.
As far as Arthur being Minister of Magic -- that is not cannon, just
a guess (I know you didn't say it was cannon, a previous poster
did). Ron has made lots of sarcastic remarks -- some of which come
true, so of which don't.
Asdie from that, there is no reason tha Arthur couldn't become
Minister, then get killed.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive