The "truth", Moody clues, James or Lily first, CoS

prpa_dbz prpa_dbz at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 30 18:39:32 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 103727

Christina: 
> Out of all the books it seems that CoS is the *odd one out*. 
> It does have VM in it but as a memory in a diary, a young Tom 
> Riddle. I'm sure this means something and will tie together 
> things in future books, but I'm not really sure I know right 
> now what CoS was supposed to tell the readers. What new 
> information came to light in CoS? Harry didn't have to fight 
> present day VM in this one - he fought the  basilisk and 
> destroyed the diary - and Memory!Tom - but what else did we 
> really discover that are supposed to be clues?

How is CoS any odder than PoA? In Prisoner Harry fights less of Voldemort than he 
does in CoS. At least he fights a younger Voldy. In PoA he fights the dementors, 
and for the Quidditch Cup, until JKR switches the plots on us, then he's fighting 
against Pettigrew. So, I think PoA is the only one in which Harry doesn't fight 
Voldy.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive