Rats at Hogwarts (was Cedric and Pettigrew)
drjuliehoward
drjuliehoward at yahoo.com
Tue Mar 2 17:54:09 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 91910
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Jo Hill <jojobinks1983 at y...>
wrote:
> Carol wrote:
> > And he would have made the exception twice, once
> > for Percy as a first-year (he would have acquired
> > Scabbers when he was about five) and again for Ron
> > as a first-year (Percy gave Scabbers to Ron after
> > he was rewarded for becoming a prefect by being
> > given his own owl, Hermes).
>
> Hi, it just occurred to me, why didn't Dumbledore twig that
Scabbers was getting on a bit, it must have been nine years old! Was
he a magic rat- <snip> Jo
Which brings me to a few questions:
(1) Have we ever found out just where Percy got the rat? (I
remember a string of posts on this earlier.)
(2) Did DD know about the marauders being animagi?
(3) If "yes" do you suppose he had a hunch that Scabbers was
actually PP and allowed him in Hogwarts to keep an eye on him? I'm
not suggesting he knew about PP being the secret keeper/traitor and
Sirius beig innocent. I'm just speculating that DD recognized
PP/Scabbers, wondered why he was in rat form and in this form for
sooooo long, and chose to keep him around to watch. DD doesn't act
hasty, nor does he disclose all he ponders.
(4) For that matter, could he have found PP/rat and gave it to Percy
for precisely that reason? He knew Percy would go to Hogwarts as
would all other Weasleys. When Ron got prefect, he wondered what
kind of "gift" he would receive because his older brothers did
(stated in post above). Given that canon evidence, another Weasley
tradition would very likely being passing down clothes, robes,
books, and pets. So, DD could anticipate that whichever Weasley had
PP/rat, it would be at Hogwarts, thus motivating him to give it
(anonymously?) as a pet.
Just some thoughts.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive