JKR Chat "The Crucial and Central Question"

[Molly Rahe]

No: HPFGUIDX 92023

This was a question from the book day webchat:

 "Right at the beginning, when Voldermort tried to kill Harry, how did
Voldermort and Harry both survive? *Schools Competition Winner*
JK Rowling replies -> That is the crucial and central question and if
I answered it there would be hardly any point writing books six and
seven... so I won't! "


So my question to you all, what is your theory's behind this?
Could it be possible that they are one and the same, why the prophecy
states that neither can live in the same world together, (or what ever
exactly it says)? Are Voldemort and Harry the same, but seperated by
timetravel, loss of memory, some magical event?

Or is it the Lily theory? With her love being stronger than death, and
that is also how Harry manages to kill voldy in the end?

I don't have any firm theory's, and I am asking you for yours!
But wasn't it cool to be there when she was asnwering questions! 


Why?! oh Why?! for love of God did stupid questions get past whomever
was monitering this?
We could have found out for once and all if Blaise was a girl or a boy
or asked good stuff on Snape and the Mauraders or even the Dumbleron
Theory, but NOOO!! We found out for the 100th time how quidditch was
formed. Bleah! Well, I am still very very gratfull she did the chat!

Sorry if this post is like another ones, I haven't read all the
current ones before I posted this. Shame on me if this is a repeat!

Twiggymolly