How did Hagrid fly? Was:Chat response (motorbike/Ginny's and Molly's names)

Susan Miller constancevigilance at yahoo.com
Fri Mar 5 18:32:10 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 92224

--- Julie Hurdman wrote:
> 
> "How did you get here?" Harry asked, looking around
> for another boat.
> 
> "Flew," said Hagrid.
> 
> "*Flew?*"
> 
> Flew on what? We know from QTTA that no spell has been
> invented that enables humans to fly unaided (I'm
> moving and I've packed FBAWTFT and QTTA, so I don't
> have the exact quote. But you can bet my HP books will
> be travelling on my person! *g*). It then goes on to
> tell about the development of the broom.
> 
<snip speculative discussion about flying to the rock on the 
motorbike>

Constance Vigilance:

My vote is for a Thestral trip. This helps solve the riddle of how 
Hagrid could find them on the rock anyway (Thestrals are good at 
finding things), how he could have landed without alerting anyone, 
and how there was no evidence of his transport (the Thestral landed, 
Hagrid dismounted and the Thestral flew away).

CV, congratulating Pippin on wiggling out of the apparently 
overwhelming evidence that Snape is no vampire. Oh, and Quirrell 
Lives!





More information about the HPforGrownups archive