SHIP: Harry/Hermione
whimsyflower
profwildflower at mindspring.com
Sat Mar 6 05:02:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 92297
As I've read through the H/H SHIP posts, I noticed that the "clues" Hermione
has given us haven't been posted yet.
In SS (chapter 16, "Through the Trapdoor"), after Hermione solved Snape's
puzzle, JKR tells us, "Hermione's lip trembled, and she suddenly dashed at
Harry and threw her arms around him." Her concern was that Harry be
careful and survive whatever he met next.
In COS Rowling tells us (chapter 18, "Dobby's Reward"), "Harry didn't know
whether the best bit was Hermione's running towrds him, screaming, 'You
solved it! You solved it!' She seems to give Harry all the credit here even
though Ron helped solve it every bit as much as Harry did.
In POA H & H have the intense adventure of using the Time-Turner to
rescue Sirius. I don't remember any spontaneous expressions of affection
from Hermione, but they seemed to work well together, and IMHO they were
very much "equal partners."
At the end of GOF she spontaneously kisses Harry on the cheek at King's
Cross Station (last page of the book).
In OOTP she greeted Harry effusively when he arrive at Grimauld Place, and
at the end of the book, again at King's Cross Station, (chapter 38, "The
Second War Begins") "Hermione disengaged herself gently from her mother
to join the group" that spoke with the Dursleys about how they treat Harry
when he is in their home. I confess: I was surprised Ron didn't join the group,
too.
When taken singlely all of these seem like very small "clues," but they are
consistent, and they represent a small cresendo of emotional intensity. I
suppose one possibility could be that Hermione falls for Harry while Ron falls
for Hermione -- uck!
These clues aside, I reluctantly admit that I think in the end it will be a H/R
SHIP. I find their rows quite persuasive; no one fights like that unless s/he
care about each other. And, on a different tack, there's the blood issue. Ron
is a pureblood, and Hermione is a Muggle. In chapter 7 of COS Ron says,
"Most wizards these days are half-blood anyway. If we hadn't maried
Muggles we'd've died out." As much as I dislike the G/H SHIP, the blood
issue is similar: Ginny is a pureblood, and Harry is a half-blood. H/H would
be too much Muggle. I know JKR often has characters say that blood doesn't
mean anything (eg: Hagrid in COS), but I wonder if blood plays a role in
partnerships.
That's it. G'night. Whimsy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive