Stopper in Death
Erin
erinellii at yahoo.com
Sat Mar 6 17:29:29 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 92323
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, cora_dee <cora_dee at w...> wrote:
> Great group, great discussions! I'm very happy to have found you :)
Erin:
Glad you did! I was just going to breeze on by this, but then I
noticed that it hadn't been answered yet, and it would be a pity if
no one answered your first post.
Cora_Dee:
> You all know Snape's Speech about the art of potion making. And you
remember that line about "putting a stopper in death".
>
> Well ... let's play! If that's the special ability potion making
offers to a master - whose death is Snape going to stopper?
>
> Harry? Dumbledore? Voldemort? Sirius? Anyone else's?
Erin:
This was my first reading of it also, actually, that Snape had the
ability to stop someone's death. But I soon found most people think
he is refering to poison, as in "I can put a stopper in a vial of
poison(death)."
But supposing he really *can* stop death, I think he's already helped
Voldemort on that front. Voldemort says in the Graveyard
(paraphrasing here) that one of his many experiments must have
worked, because he didn't die when the AK rebounded on him. I think
it likely that an experiment or two involved some potion from Severus.
Erin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive