Snape as the faithful servant

jojobinks1983 jojobinks1983 at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Mar 6 22:37:53 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 92363

Hi, just thought I'd complicate matters a little. Why does Crouch Junior!
Moody have to be the "faithful servant" (I haven't seen this one on 
the board, I don't think). It is highly likely that he 
is but there is wiggling room, and if it were Snape then the rest of 
the mysteries could be solved- his relationship with Malfoy, his 
absence at the graveyard, even his little run in with Quirrell in 
P/S. We know he's an occlumens so there is a real possibility that he 
could hoodwink Voldie. Also I've been thinking about other 
possibilities for the mystery trio of absent death eaters:

1. Coward: Karkaroff (obviously), Bagman (possibly-he did run away as 
well)
2. "one who has left forever": Crouch Junior (he was sort of "killed"), 
Karkaroff again...
3. Faithful Servant: Snape, Crouch Junior, Karkaroff (did Voldie know 
that he'd done a runner?), the portrait under Dumbledore's bed...

I happily await a barrage of outraged backhanders,

Jo, who really loves the idea that Snape is a deliciously evil double 
agent just waiting to be rescued by his own conscience.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive