Malfoy/Karkaroff

eloise_herisson eloiseherisson at aol.com
Wed Mar 10 16:46:18 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 92668

lizvega2:

> If Karkaroff was released from prison for 
> incriminating the other DE's (There's no mention of Lucius at 
> Karkaroff's hearing) why would Lucius want to send his son to a 
> traitor for wizard training? Even LV knows in the graveyard scene 
in 
> GOF that Lucius hasn't renounced the 'old' ways. 

It's not clear how public this hearing was or whether the proceedings 
were publicised beyond those present in the chamber at the time.

Karkaroff named Snape, remember and there is no evidence elsewhere in 
the books that anyone other than Dumbledore and those involved in the 
WW hearings knew his past before the end of GoF.

So perhaps Lucius simply did not know that Karkaroff was a traitor.

~Eloise





More information about the HPforGrownups archive