Is Hermione Older or Younger than Harry?

[rorogersmc]

No: HPFGUIDX 92720

I'm responding generally, and not specifically to everyones comments.  Also, I don't 
expect what I have to say to clear up the confusion, just add something to think 
about.
How do we know that the decision of when students start at Hogwarts by their age, is 
based on the school year, and not the calendar year?  Lots of schools, maybe even 
most schools admit students by when their birthday falls in relation to the school 
year.  However, not meaning to get religious, but to illustrate.  All of my sunday 
school classes were based on calendar year.  Because of this, I actually had sunday 
school classes with others who where in a different school grade than I was.
Anyway, this is just a thought I've been having, not a meaningful solution.

Rachael