SHIP: Harry and Hermione together per JKR chat?
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Fri Mar 12 16:03:23 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 92821
Pippin previously
> > Hermione worked awfully hard to get Ron and Harry back
> > together in GoF.
Great Elder One:
> Possibly because she understood that the three of them were
stronger together than apart.<
Then surely Ron has some redeeming qualities in her eyes <g>
Pippin previously:
> > Alot of Hermione's social development seems to be more
down to Ron than Harry. Ron's the one who gets her to play
games, takes her on her first visit to Hogsmeade, invites her to
stay with his family,<<
Great Elder One
> I really don't understand how these points are significant for
social development. I agree Ron helps her adjust to the magical
world just as he did for Harry however I'm sure she probably did
all these things in her previous years when she wasn't attending
Hogwarts. Besides none of these things are things that go
against her nature imo.<
When Ron wasn't around in GoF, Hermione spent all her time
with Harry in the Library--no games of chess or exploding snap.
It's not that having fun is against her nature, but she seems so
unsure of herself that she thinks she has to study all the time,
even though she's already the best student in her year. It's Ron
who gets her to enjoy herself, IMO. Without him, she'd be doing
her best to turn Harry into a workaholic.
Pippin continued:
>
> > and lets her know more than once
> > that being too much like Percy is not on.
Great Elder One:
> And being friends with Harry is what changes her in my frank
opinion. Who does she lie for? Who does she break the rules(
including brewing a dangerous potion, helping with an illegal
club and breaking into the headmaster's office<
Who indeed? <g> The dangerous potion was to help *her*, the
only Muggleborn in the group.No one knew that the Heir had
targeted Harry. The DA was also to help *her* and the other
students including Ron--Harry was in far less need of practical
DADA lessons than anyone else in the school. He didn't use any
spells in the combat which he didn't know already.
Breaking into Umbridge's office she did for Harry, but if she
hadn't, Sirius would still be alive, so maybe she won't be so
cooperative in the future.
>) If it wasn't for Harry she would be a very different person ditto
for Harry if Hermione wasn't there.<
True. But you could say the same about Ron.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive