Minerva McGonagall & The SS Movie Possible Clue? NOT a Coincidence

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 92849

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Frank" <fever264 at A...> wrote:
> [ELF NOTE: Just a reminder: this post is fine, as comparing the movies to canon in an 
attempt to shed further light on canon is entirely appropriate for the main list, but we do 
ask everyone to remember when replying that your posts must keep the focus on canon. If 
you'd like to discuss the movies alone, please do so on the Movie list: groups.yahoo.com/
group/HPFGU-Movie. 
> -Manya Elf, for the Admin Team]
> 
> 
> "M.G. McGonagall" 1971 on the name plate to the right of James 
> Potter. ( To the left of James is "R.J.H. KING 1969" )
> 
> Now, I only brought this up b/c of JK's role on the content of the 
> movies, I think this might of been purposely done. But I could be 
> very wrong.
> 
> Does ANYONE have any theories on this? I dont know off the top of my 
> head the exact time lines as to when McGonagall went to school, but I 
> do remember her in POA saying how she remembered James and Sirius 
> together at school while she was teaching. 
> 

This is also listed in "The Harry Potter Lexicon" in the "Who's who" section.

It's  obviously not Minerva (dates are wrong) and it seems a bit of a stretch
for it to be a  sibling (she'd be about 50 at the time).

In small print they give their opinion that because it contradicts the JKR
statement that Minerva taught at the time James was at Hogwarts, it 
must be considered that this is not canon.

Unless this turns out to be somehow associated with another of her 
statements that some of the staff had been married but that the
details were confidential at the moment.

Minerva's love child? By Flitwick? I think we should be told.

Kneasy