[HPforGrownups] Re: Weasley's ages

[danielle dassero]

No: HPFGUIDX 92994

In SS Fred says they haven't won since Charlie left.
Chap midnight duel. Since I agree that Molly would not
have let Charlie leave early, and Charlie probably
listened to his mum. And since the 93/94 schoolyear
would have been the 8 year that they would have lost
in quidditch. Then Charlie graduated in 1986. The
86/87 was year 1 lost,87/88 was year 2 lost,88/89 year
3, 89/90 year 4, 90/91 year 5,91/92 year 6,92/93 was
year 7 lost. If they had lost instead of winning then
93/94 would have been the 8th year they lost. So
depending on when Charlie's birthday was, Charlie
would have been turned 18 or 19  in 1986 that makes
him being born in 1967 or 1968. Making him 28 or 29 at
the beginning of OOP. Which would mean that JKR is
really bad at math. She is the type of writer that as
the ideas come to her she writes it down. And then not
knowing how succesful she would be,didn't stop and
look over the details like the ages. Some writers are
the type that would sit down and plan for things like
the ages. They would write out a detailed note saying
that charlie graduated in 1986 or whenever and must be
this age and them bill would be 2 years older and what
not.

And as for Bill saying how long it's been since he was
at Hogwarts, maybe since 5 years ago in GOF was the
twins 2nd year and their first on teh team. Maybe he
came down for their last Quiditch match to watch them
play because he was able to get away from his job.


DAnielle, who really thinks that while JKR writes
good, her math really sucks and so does her ability to
plan and check for the small things. LOL

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - More reliable, more storage, less spam
http://mail.yahoo.com