[HPforGrownups] Re: Weasley's ages

[danielle dassero]

No: HPFGUIDX 93148

I never said anything about the house cup. I was
talking purely quidditch and I used the 7 year mark
from POA and the we haven't won since Charlie left
school for the Quidditch game cup. 
DAnielle D

> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, danielle
> dassero <drdara at y...> wrote:
> Snip of Danielle's:
> > In SS Fred says they haven't won since Charlie
> left.
> > Chap midnight duel. Since I agree that Molly would
> not
> > have let Charlie leave early, and Charlie probably
> > listened to his mum. And since the 93/94
> schoolyear
> > would have been the 8 year that they would have
> lost
> > in quidditch. Then Charlie graduated in 1986. The
> > 86/87 was year 1 lost,87/88 was year 2 lost,88/89
> year
> > 3, 89/90 year 4, 90/91 year 5,91/92 year 6,92/93
> was
> > year 7 lost. If they had lost instead of winning
> then
> > 93/94 would have been the 8th year they lost. So
> > depending on when Charlie's birthday was, Charlie
> > would have been turned 18 or 19  in 1986 that
> makes
> > him being born in 1967 or 1968. 
> 
>  SS US Paperback Ch. 13 pg 216 it says "If they won
> their next match, against 
> Hufflepuff, they would overtake Slytherin in the
> house championship for the first time 
> in seven years."  POA US Hardcover Ch. 15 pg 301
> "Gryffindor hadn't won the 
> Quidditch Cup since the legendary Charlie Weasley
> (Ron's second oldest brother) had 
> been Seeker."
> The Quidditch Cup and the House Championship are two
> different contests.  You 
> can't assume because a house wins the Quidditch Cup
> it wins the house 
> championship and visa-versa.  In PS/SS it may have
> been 7 years since they won the 
> house championship, but you can't assume that it's
> been 7 years since they won the 
> Quidditch Cup.  It could be true, but without more
> information we just can't assume 
> things like that (ie. Charlie's last year at
> Hogwarts 1986.)
> 
> Rachael
> 
> 
> 


__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - More reliable, more storage, less spam
http://mail.yahoo.com