What's in it for Petunia?

[humantupperware1]

No: HPFGUIDX 93315


Sean wrote:
> <snip>
> Obviously she knows more than she's saying. There is nothing
> explicit about her being forced by the pact to act. She's in 
> more danger with Harry around than not - Dudley may well be a 
> Squib, as some have suggested, but that hardly gives her a 
> motive to protect Harry.
>  
> What did Dumbledore REALLY threaten her with?

Max:
<snip> 
> The theory which makes sense to me is that Dumbledore's blood charm
> protects Petunia and Dudley as well as Harry (I'm not sure how this
> might extend to Uncle Vernon).  They all share the same blood line,
> after all.  So I don't see why the protection can't extend to all 
> of them.
> 
> So, seen within this context, Petunia is definitely safer *with* 
> Harry than without.


I have small and probably ridiculous idea on this one, but I'm still 
holding out that Petunia may be a witch......I know it doesn't seem 
to make sense at first, but is it actually specifically said 
anywhere that she isn't? All I have come up with is that she is 
insistent to ignore the WW and everything in it, but I'm guessing 
that she may actually be a closet witch, trying to live a normal 
life.

Maybe? Am I dreaming?

"humantupperware1"