Horse Feathers

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 93795

vmonte wrote:
I've always had the feeling that Olivander was Flamel.
 
> JoAnna responded:
> 
> Doubtful. In SS/PS, Dumbledore tells Harry, "[Nicolas Flamel and 
> his wife, Perenelle] have enough Elixir stored to set their affairs 
> in order; then yes, they will die." (don't have my book available, 
> but it's in the last or second-to-last chapter).  I have the feeling 
> that Nicolas and Perenelle died shortly after the events of SS/PS, 
> after the stone was destroyed.  
> 
> Ollivander, however, is present for the Weighing of the Wands in 
> GoF. I sincerely doubt it took two-three years for Nicolas & 
> Perenelle Flamel to set their affairs in order, and if so I doubt 
> NicolasFlamel!Ollivander would continue working at his wand shop if 
> he had so much to do.

Carol:
I agree completely with Joanna. One more small point. Flamel's picture
is in the chocolate frog cards. If he's looked exactly like
Ollivander, Harry would have noticed it.

Carol, who wonders whether Ollivander could be related to Luna because
they have similar eyes