sirius as animagus - why didn't the deatheaters know pre OOP?

rtb333 rtb333 at yahoo.com
Thu Mar 25 11:56:01 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 93909

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "suehpfan" <stanleys at s...> 
wrote:
> 
> Two points from me...
> 
> They were only a few years out of school and although the were 
doing 
> important work for the Order (they would not have had to defy Lord 
> Thingy "thrice" if they weren't) they were probably a little 
> concerned about telling DD about their transgressions in school.  
> They still did not know whom they could trust for sure either, they 
> even doubted each other. Obviously, they should have doubted each 
> other even more.
> 
> As a side note, the DE's knew about the Marauder's alter egos 
because 
> of Wormtail.  He no longer hid his ability and certainly would have 
> also shared the info about the others.  In the very beginning of 
> OotP, it was Malfoy who made the "dogging" comment.  Obviously 
Peter 
> wasted no time in sharing his information with all the DEs now that 
> he was officially one of them.

Enter Rob(Who has been watching this discussion hoping someone thinks 
like he does)

It is actually quite simple if you think about it.  Who knows that 
the Maurauders are anamagi?  Just the four.  If somehow the enemy 
knew that they were anamagi, it is apparent that one of the four is a 
spy.  This information was held back so that PP could keep his 
cover.  I think that it is that simple.  

Rob(Stepping back into the shadows)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive