[HPforGrownups] Here's a Crazy thought...

[Silverthorne]

No: HPFGUIDX 94122

{mo}

Well, here's a thought, albeit a crazy one.  There has
been numerous discussion about how did DD find out
about HP's mom saving his life before HP told him;
someone else had to be at Godric's Hollow that
evening, etc.
Well, what if Snape was there and was involved in
saving Harry?  What if it was Snape that brought about
LV downfall? (Sort of a countercharm INCLUDING all
three Snape, HP, and Lily.)
Then, that WOULD make certain that Snape was the "one
who left forever"

{Silverthorne}

Actaully, I can see something like this--I'm not sure he would have helped
in Lily's charm. (The indications seem to point to a situation where Lily
was on her onw by then)..but he might have been the first on the scene
(perhaps accompanying Voldemort in his dutiful role as 'faithful DE'--went
to do something else while Voldy 'took care' of Lily and Harry, or perhaps
followed and was part of the mop-up.)

{Mo}

And, how about this too...
Snape was always a member of the order and he went
undercover on DD's orders and purposely became a DE
JUST so he could get on the inside.  Basically, he was
the member who risked the most out of any of them.
So, he was NEVER a REAL DE, but just posing as one all
along, doing the most dirty work.. ???

{Silverthorne}

Again, nice thought, but DD imdicates he really *was* a DE that turned away
from that path....


Anne