Remus & Sirius (Was: DD + Lupin - Nature of Secret Charm)

newdella Rosebeth710 at hotmail.com
Sat May 1 00:22:00 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 97373

Julia:
> IMO the events happened in that order:
> 1. Voldemort comes to the Potters, kills Lily and James, tries to 
kill Harry
> (knocks down the hause), disappears
> 2. DD somehow knows what happened and sends Hagrid for Harry
> 3. Hagrid and Sirius arrive at the scene at nearly the same time. 
They both
> are able to see what happened because there is no hause.
> 4. Sirius decides to run after Peter, Hagrid takes Harry and 
Sirius's bike
> and off he goes.
> 
> I know that 2. is not "complete" but I just can't think of any way 
how DD
> got to know what happened. You say it was Lupin who told him, but I 
think
> that no one knew the secret.  

As I was reading this post a thought came to me as to how DD knew of 
the events at GH.  There is no cannon that I know of to prove it, so 
it's pure theory.  But we know from OotP that people in their 
portraits can move from one location to another.  What if there was 
a  portrait hanging in the sitting room of GH and the person 
portrayed in was also a former Headmaster/mistress?  As soon as LV 
comes in the door the person in the portrait reports to DD who sends 
Hagrid to retreive Harry, if he's still alive.  

Do with it what you will.

Rosebeth





More information about the HPforGrownups archive