[HPforGrownups] What about Tonks? Evil or good?

[Miss Melanie]

No: HPFGUIDX 97393

vmonte wrote:
If she is evil will she morph into Voldemort, or one of the children, 
to lure Harry into a trap?  And will someone realize that it is her 
when she falls down a flight of stairs? 

My reply:  I don't think she is evil, why?  Well, I mean for all practical purposes her lineage would suggest that she isn't.  I have no proof but my guess she was in Gryffindor, I just believe that her mother, Andromeda, was.  I think perhaps that might have encouraged Sirius to go into the house, or at least helped him to decide that.  And if nothing else we can all agree that standing up to your very evil family and marrying a muggle born is extremely brave!  
 
For that reason alone I just can't see Tonks being evil.  She was brought up in a family where the death eater attitude was not looked highly upon.  She isn't even on the Black family tree and well, while she is clumsy at some points.  I've noticed that this is very observable in scenes where she appears to be nervous.  I'm sorry Molly is enough to make me nervous and knock things over also.  However, she does appear to be able to control it a good portion of the time.  
 
So no I don't think she is evil.  She is one of those characters that one would have to really prove hard that she is evil.  
 
~Melanie



		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Win a $20,000 Career Makeover at Yahoo! HotJobs 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]