[HPforGrownups] Snape's reporting methods

[Miller, Gina (JIS)]

No: HPFGUIDX 97625

Tanya wrote:

Right, reading this, it had me wondering.  I have heard often that Snape is
likely to report regularly to Dumbledore, and as these are Dumbledore's
personal memories.  I wonder if the fact that Snape is not looking at
Dumbledore while talking, whether that actually helps him with
occulumcy.  If he doesn't have a visual memory........................

Thoughts anyone?

<sorry had to snip a lot>

 
Gina: I thought he was talking to the ceiling because the penseive is a bowl
and anyone in it would seem to be looking up at the ceiling. Your point was
good if that is the case, but I think it just appeared to Harry that Snape
was talking to the ceiling because Harry was looking down into the penseive.