Where do teachers live?

Susan teilani2002 at yahoo.com
Mon May 3 19:31:26 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 97631

Potioncat:  " What gets me is whether they [the students] wear 
Muggle
> > type clothing under the  robes (as in the movies) or whether the 
robes
> > are their clothes.(as  in the Pensieve scene.)"
> > 
> > The Muggle-borns wear Muggle clothes under the robes almost for 
sure,
> > and the wizard borns often don't, is my guess.  I think that it's
> > little things like this and big things too that offend the
> > "purebloods" as they watch Muggle culture influence wizard 
culture. 
> 
> 
Carol:
> That's would be my guess, too, except that IIRC the boys ask 
Hermione
> to leave so they can change to their robes in the first Hogwarts
> Express scene in SS/PS, so it sounds as if they intend to take off 
the
> Muggle clothes. I'm guessing that even the pureblood students 
probably
> wear Muggle clothes for the trip to and from the Hogwarts Express 
but
> not the rest of the time--except for shoes, socks, and underwear. 
The
> Muggle-borns probably follow their example after a while--maybe when
> they see the lousy job the House Elves have done laundering their
> Muggle clothes. ;-)
> 
> Some of the older purebloods apparently skip even the underwear:
> Remember old Archie at the Tri-Wizard tournament who won't exchange
> his flowered nightgown for a pair of Muggle trousers because 
he "likes
> a nice breeze around his privates"?  
> 
>  No school uniforms, either; just plain black robes
> for everyday wear.
> 
Yeah, I've often wondered about the clothes myself.  First of all, 
I'm pretty sure it gets quite cold in the winter.  Surely they'd have 
something on underneath their robes, esp when they're going outside 
for Hagrid's class or to watch a Quidditch match.  Also, on the 
convers of the books (US) HP is in jeans and a shirt... while on his 
broom (SS) and on Buckbeak(PoA).  And while we're at it, these aren't 
children, these are teens.  I would imagine, with adolescence coming 
on, that it might be a good idea for young boys and girls to have 
clothes on under their robes!

Also, I've been thinking about all the adults at the World Quidditch 
thing who don't know how to dress themselves muggle-style.  Perhaps, 
being adults, presumably employed, but even if not, still surrounded 
by no one else but other wizards, etc., they maybe forgot how to 
dress like they did as kids.  I mean, they haven't had to wear 
anything except their robes for years and years (and they live so 
long!).  

Furthermore, the adults haven't had to mix with muggles in ages, 
whereas obviously some of the students at Hogwarts have muggle 
parents, so these kids certainly would be seen by the other 
students.  And as was mentioned earlier (I may have snipped it out, 
so sorry), the students did comment on their classmates' new clothes, 
hairstyles, etc. And in one of the movies, IIRC, doesn't Hermione 
have on a tie under her robe, a la private school uniforms?  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive