DD=Harry?!

[gsanderson at cfl.rr.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 97672

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Damit Lazarus" <lkotur at y...> 
wrote:
> animallover_11:
> 
> > If DD is Harry that would explain how he knew what happened at GH 
> because he was there.  There has also been discussions around about 
> how Dobby was able to go to help Harry..well Dobby eventually was 
> working for DD.  DD is always very careful in choosing his words to 
> explain situations.  
> > 
> 
> My first thought was Dumbledore could not be Harry since Dumbledore 
> does not have the scar.  However, when Harry finally disposes of 
> Lord Voldermort, the scar may just disappear.  
> 
> Larry
> 
> D.I.L.

There's no way we can know for sure until the end, but I can think of 
several things to point out 

1. DD's reaction during the Fake!Moody revelation.  When Fake!Moody 
mentioned the Marauder's Map, DD acted with genuine surprise.  Also, 
if DD was Harry, he would already know that Fake!Moody was Crouch Jr. 
and that Professor Quirrell was bad in the first book, etc.  
2. There would also have to be an explanation for DD's brother and 
for the account of DD taking his Newt exams (mentioned in book 5) I 
think with Prof. Marchbanks.  If DD were Harry, then Marchbanks would 
have recognized that during these Owls.  
3. They share no physical characteristics (eyes, hair, etc...)  


Kristen