Help with Lupin's boggart / Cockroaches

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 97705

snip snip 
Carol wrote:
> 
> I think that other reference to Lupin's boggart being 
unceremoniously
> dismissed without a perceptible Riddikulus spell is in one of the
> boggart!dementor lessons in PoA, possibly the one where Harry hears
> James. (And yes, I do think it's James. He would know if it was 
Lupin.)
> 
> Carol, who is probably trying to have it both ways in this post
> because she sees both sides


Potioncat:
I think I'm getting "too good" at snipping.  Yes, I also see both 
possibilites for the boggart and for a foreboding of foresight, so 
we'll see how it plays out.

I think it's James too, because his mother says, "Your father is 
coming" and I don't think Lily's echo would say that if it wasn't his 
father's echo.  Nor do I think any husband in his right mind would 
switch with another man and not tell his wife.

No one else seems at all interested in the way Lupin sometimes 
dispels his Boggart. It does nag at me though.
Potioncat