Inaugural address and Mandy Croyance on Assumption

pippin_999 foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu May 6 16:59:45 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 97792

Mandy Croyance:

>>Out side of the box is where we need to roam. If Hagrid was 
wrong about `all dark wizards' then perhaps he was wrong about 
something else. Dumbledore's own judgment was called into 
question andgenerally proven faulty in the fifth book. We can no 
longer assume that because Harry Potter agrees with 
something we should nor can we afford to buy into an ideology 
just because it is supported by theprotagonists.

Who knows? Maybe we really are rooting for the wrong side.<<

Depends what you mean by "side". Will friendship and bravery 
triumph over treachery and cowardice? Almost certainly. But the 
true and the brave may be found in other Houses as well as 
Gryffindor (Cedric, Luna, Snape), while some Gryffindors may 
find their youthful aspirations slipping perilously beyond their 
grasp (Peter and ??).

Pippin





More information about the HPforGrownups archive